Should I Repair or Replace My Phone?

In this article, we'll break down how to decide, compare the cost of repairing vs. replacing your phone, and explore other factors so you can make the smartest choice for your budget and needs.

Repair vs. replace: Which makes more sense?

Factor	Repair your phone if…	Replace your phone if…
Device age	The phone is under 3 years old and/or still gets software or security updates.	The phone is 3+ years old, no longer supported, or noticeably slower.
Repair cost	Fixing it costs less than 20% of the phone’s current market value.	Repairs cost more than 20–50% of what a comparable new phone would cost.
Damage type	The issue is minor - cracked screen, dead battery, charging port, or camera lens.	The damage is extensive - water damage, motherboard failure, or multiple problems at once.
Performance	The device still meets your everyday needs and runs smoothly after repair.	You need better performance, improved battery life, or new features like 5G or upgraded cameras.
Sustainability	You want to reduce e-waste and extend your phone’s lifespan.	You prefer a longer-term solution with the latest tech and improved efficiency.
Warranty coverage	The device is under warranty or covered by insurance.	Warranty coverage has expired or repairs may void protection.
Convenience	You can go a few days without your phone for a repair.	You need a quick replacement and can’t afford downtime.

Should I repair my phone? 5 scenarios

Repairing can be the right call when your device still functions well overall. 5 common scenarios include:

Minor issues like a cracked screen, short-lived battery, or broken charging port.
Repair costs that are a small fraction of a new phone - usually under 20%.
Recent devices (under 3 years old) that still get software updates and perform smoothly.
Warranty or insurance coverage that reduces or eliminates repair costs.
Sustainability goals, such as keeping electronics out of landfills.

A new screen repair can cost $100–$300 or more, while battery replacements usually range from $50–$100 or more. These quick fixes can add another year or two to your phone’s lifespan for a fraction of what a new model costs.

If your device is still doing everything you need - streaming, messaging, browsing - repairing can be the more cost-effective and eco-friendly option.

Should I replace my phone? 5 scenarios

Sometimes repairs aren’t worth the money, time, or trouble. Here are 5 examples of when replacing might be smarter:

Multiple problems at once, such as a cracked screen and weak battery.
Repair costs that climb above 20–50% of the phone’s value.
Older device no longer gets operating system or security updates.
Performance issues, like freezing apps or sluggish response times.
Desire for new features, such as better cameras, faster processors, or longer battery life.

A new phone often costs $400–$1,000 or more, but it brings long-term benefits: multi-year software support, advanced hardware, and efficiency improvements. If your device feels outdated or the repair would only be a short-term fix, replacing it can save you headaches in the long run.

Cost breakdown: Repair vs. replacement

Understanding the price differences can help you make the best decision for you.

Repair Type	Average Cost Range
Screen replacement	$100–$300 or more
Battery replacement	$50–$100 or more
Charging port repair	$75–$150 or more
Camera or speaker repair	$75–$200 or more
Water-damage restoration	$100–$400 or more (varies by severity)

Generally speaking, new or refurbished phone may cost anywhere in the following ranges:

New budget-friendly phone: $150-$250
New midrange phone: around $400–$700 or more
New flagship phone: around $800–$1,200 or more
Refurbished/used phones: around $150–$500 or more

A helpful rule of thumb: If repair costs exceed 20-30% of the price of a comparable new phone, replacement typically makes more financial sense. Also factor in trade-in value. Even older or damaged phones may qualify for credit toward a newer model, which can reduce upgrade costs significantly.

Repairing vs. replacing: 3 environmental considerations

Choosing to repair instead of replace can be a small but meaningful way to reduce electronic waste (e-waste). Here are 3 reasons to consider repairing when possible:

Repairs extend device lifespan, keeping phones in use longer and delaying the environmental cost of manufacturing new ones.
Smartphones contain rare metals like gold, lithium, and cobalt that are energy-intensive to extract.
Recycling options vary by region, and not all phones sent for disposal are processed responsibly.

If sustainability is part of your decision, repairing or buying refurbished helps conserve resources and cut down on landfill waste.

Final decision-making checklist

Before you decide whether to repair or replace your phone, ask yourself 5 quick questions:

Is the repair less than 20% of my phone’s current value?
Will the fix resolve all major issues (and not just one of many)?
Does the phone still meet my needs for speed, storage, and camera quality?
Is the device less than three years old and still getting updates?
Am I comfortable keeping this model for at least another year?

If you answered “yes” to most of these, repair may be the smarter, greener choice. If not, it might be time to explore a replacement or upgrade.

15 FAQs about repairing or replacing your phone

Should I repair or replace my phone?

If the phone is newer, repairable for under 20% of its value, and still meets your needs, repair it. If it’s aging, sluggish, or costly to fix, replacing offers better value.

Is it cheaper to repair or replace a phone?

Repairs are generally cheaper upfront. Replacements make sense when repair costs are high or the phone is nearing the end of its support life.

Is it better to repair or replace a phone with a cracked screen?

If the screen repair is reasonably priced and the phone performs well otherwise, repair it. If it’s also old or slow, replacement may be worth considering.

What is the average cost to repair a phone screen?

Expect roughly $100–$300 or more depending on the model and screen type.

Can I replace just the battery instead of the whole phone?

Yes. Replacing a worn-out battery (around $50–$100 or more) can restore performance and extend the life of your phone.

How old is too old to repair a phone?

Once a phone is 4–5 years old and no longer gets updates, holds a charge, or runs essential apps smoothly, repairs are usually not worth it.

Does a manufacturer repair phones out of warranty?

Many manufacturers and authorized shops do, though prices may be higher than third-party repair services.

What if my phone has water damage?

Mild water exposure might be repairable for $100–$400 or more, but severe internal damage often leads to full replacement.

What are signs that my battery needs replacing?

Frequent charging, rapid battery drain, or the phone shutting off unexpectedly are common indicators.

Are refurbished phones worth considering?

Absolutely. Refurbished phones can cost 30–50% less than new models and still offer strong performance and warranties.

Does replacing the screen affect resale value?

A professionally replaced screen can preserve resale value, while DIY or poor-quality repairs can reduce it.

How long does a phone repair usually take?

Most common fixes - screens, batteries, ports – can take 1–3 days, depending on part availability.

Is it safe to use third-party repair shops?

Yes, if the shop uses quality parts and offers a warranty on its work. Always check reviews before choosing a provider.

Can I trade in a damaged phone?

Often yes. Many carriers and resellers accept devices with moderate wear or damage, applying a reduced trade-in credit.

What should I do before recycling or trading in my phone?

Back up your data, sign out of all accounts, perform a factory reset, and remove SIM and memory cards.

The bottom line for phone replacement or repair

Deciding whether to repair or replace your phone comes down to cost, performance, and longevity. If repairs are minor, affordable, and your phone still meets your needs - fix it and enjoy a few more years of use. If repairs are expensive, updates have stopped, or performance is fading - replace it for a fresh start and new capabilities.

When it’s time to upgrade, compare your choices. Explore certified refurbished models, trade-in programs, and carrier deals to find the right balance of performance, price, and sustainability.

You may also be interested in:

^Sources: